Archive for www.regdafishthinktank.com Here in the Day
 


       www.regdafishthinktank.com Forum Index -> Fishy Tales
Late Doors

On The Black Hill, Bruce Chatwin

Never heard of the book or the author until I picked this up a couple of weeks ago. It was in a bundle left by MrsD's sister who sadly passed away last year. I'd been contemplating a list of things to read but thought knackers to lists just get something and read it. So glad I did as this book has proved to be a real gem that has kind of taken over my thought processes a little this last week.

Set in and amongst the Welsh-English border it takes the rural agricultural existence of its characters, their entwined  lives and layers them across much of the last century reflecting the earth and seasons around them. Events come and go with sadness, pathos, warmth, resigned comedy and a massive dose of stoicism, for that is the country way. Some petty some huge but all draw you into the seething normality of life in the farms. Not a drama or thriller or in any way sentimental yet filled me with more emotion and empathy than any cheesy Hollywood effort.
Dock

Sounds great LD. Good review! I've seen his books in shops but never picked them up. Just googled him, looks like quite the 'windswept and interesting' type.
Plastic Man

Re: On The Black Hill, Bruce Chatwin

Late Doors wrote:
Set in and amongst the Welsh-English border it takes the rural agricultural existence of its characters, their entwined  lives and layers them across much of the last century reflecting the earth and seasons around them. Events come and go with sadness, pathos, warmth, resigned comedy and a massive dose of stoicism, for that is the country way. Some petty some huge but all draw you into the seething normality of life in the farms. Not a drama or thriller or in any way sentimental yet filled me with more emotion and empathy than any cheesy Hollywood effort.


Sounds akin to one of my favourites, "Cider with Rosie". How does it compare?
Late Doors

Good Comparison. Similarities in setting culture and tempo but Cider with Rosie focuses on a coming of age youthful angle with maybe more emphasis on nostalgia. On Black Hill is bleaker and starker and takes a wider age span rather than a focus on the post war (first) period which I think Cider does but yep the two do bare comparison
Cutsyke

Have some parts of On Patagonia been discredited? I'm sure I read that somewhere.
Late Doors

Dunno, never even heard of him before i read this book. Had a quick look on G and couldnt find anything to suggest it has. I still have flashbacks to Black Hill. Thats the sighn of a great read for me, when you find yourself thinking back to it months after
Cutsyke

In Patagonia, sorry. Looked into it a bit, it seems some of the people in Argentina were critical of the way he'd reported some events. It is a great book, a travel memoir rather than a novel, which I believe Black Hill to be.

In fact, I'm going to go pick a copy up on the way to work. Not sure where mine is.

       www.regdafishthinktank.com Forum Index -> Fishy Tales
Page 1 of 1
Create your own free forum | Buy a domain to use with your forum
I told you. We're an anarcho-syndicalist commune